Luck delivered me: first, my overnight bus from São Paulo happened to cross the path of the MST march less than 10km outside of the capitol, Brasília. And then, after retracing my path in a quick taxi ride, it took only 15 minutes of disoriented wandering before I ran into my one and only acquaintance at the march, Diana (quite a trick in a chaotic temporary encampment of thousands). Not half an hour later I was badged, handed a hot lunch, and for all intents and purposes an official particpant. And I still didn't quite know what I was doing there; sure, I'd just finished reading
To Inherit the Earth, the best and most recent English-language book on the MST, but my Portuguese was decidedly shaky after several weeks of fraternizing in English--interviewing people about their motivations as I had planned just didn't seem realistic.
But if there's one thing I can learn from the MST, it's this: sometimes you just have to simply occupy a space, and if you hold onto it, then people will recognize your place there.
MSwhat?The Movimento dos Trabalhadores Sem Terra (best translated as Landless Worker's Movement) is, if not the largest, then certainly one of the largest social justice movements in the world. Counting roughly two million participants, the organization seeks to push through agrarian reform (i.e. redistribution of land ownership from a few large landholders to many small landholders) in Brasil as means of both giving livelihoods to poor people and redistributing power in Brasilian society. The MST is particularly famous because its members occupy unused plots of land owned by large landholders and tenaciously stick out intimidation and violence until the government officially recognizes them, transfering deed of the land and providing services and credit. (Interestingly, this is done in accordance to a principle written into the constitution that declares all land "not serving its social purpose" is subject to claim by those who work it.) And it has been effective: starting with its first
accampamento, or occupation, in 1986, the MST is responsible for getting roughly 300,000 occupations officially recognized while pushing the issue of agrarian reform into the terms of national debate, among other accomplishments. (There is so much I could write about it, but I would direct you to the aforementioned book or
their site (in Portuguese;
here's an English language affiliate) to learn more.)
While I had heard the name in the US, I didn't encounter the MST until I got to the World Social Forum, and even then I didn't get to learn much, due to my language incapacities. Turns out it something of a darling among social/economic justice activists, given its effectiveness, confrontational tactics, and solid alliances with environmental and indigenous rights movements. But perhaps most impressive of all is the fact that so many poor and uneducated people are so strongly self-organized.
OrganizedI have never seen such an effective operation for moving what was in fact a small city. The National March for Agrarian Reform, as it was called, was a behemoth just by the numbers:
- 12,000 marchers (arrived on 400 buses)
- 200+ kilometers of marching (from Goiana to Brasília) over the course of 16 days
- 3,000 event organizers trained, divided by sector (health, communications, discipline, etc.)
- 12 600-person tents and 20 200-person tents pitched every night (carried in 24 trucks)
- 22,000 meals delivered daily by 1,200 cooks organized into 23 kitchens (one for each state represented)
- 250,000 liters of water disbursed daily by 10 water trucks
- 100 chemical bathrooms set up daily, carried by 3 trucks
- 8 ambluances taking roughly 50 cases per day
- 3 soundtrucks and 3,000+ hand radios blaring the emissions of 1 mobile radio broadcast booth
And yet it never appeared to be anything but running smoothly. Moreover, there was a fairly standard daily schedule, which consisted of: waking anywhere between 4am and 6am, camp packed and on the road 2 hours later, walking 4 - 6 hours, pitching camp, brief rest, afternoon political discussion sessions, dinner, then free time/going to sleep.
ArrivalAfter taking a meal of rice & beans with the Bahia camp, I pitch my tent--which amused quite a number of people, being a single-sized mosquito net tent (called later "the tent with all the holes")--and take to wandering the camp for the day. A majority of people are dead asleep under the gigantic canvas tents; the tiredness of MST members is palpable, this being the 15th day on the road. Nevertheless, there is activity everywhere: people playing guitars, playing cards, chatting and joking, passing around giant cups of maté tea...the energy one would expect of a small city in the early afternoon.

Soon I run into a number of youth meetings, where the under-25 crowds sit in circles of political discussions and cheer contests, the latter bearing a striking resemblance to traditional "summer camp" activities. (I would be reminded of this sense time and again.) My disused Portuguese cannot keep up with it, and as the meetings dissolve into regular socializing and backflip contests, I wander off only to find a group crowded around the day's newspapers stories, which had been pasted up on the side of a bus for public viewing. Some articles are fair reportage, but others horribly and inappropriately biased (the powers-that-be have painted the organization as violent and seditious). Specifically, an impatient motorist that tried to drive through the marchers the day before got his windows broken and doors bashed in; this is the day's lede, and it elicits a constant stream of curses from each new person that comes up to read the headlines.

(If it's not appearing, just click the frame.)
Weaving in and out of different the different camps, I soon came across an interesting looking meeting and stop to listen. My presence is distinctly noticed, as I meet many sets of eyes on me, and though the meeting proceeds I am soon confronted by a fellow asking, "Hi, um, who are you?" I begin to explain, and thankfully it rapidly becomes clear that I am an oblivious foreigner. The fellow smiles, explains that it is a coordinators' meeting and implies that I seemed suspicious.
OutsiderUndoubtedly, everyone during the march viewed me with at least a little suspicion, and for good reason: no one knew me, I didn't speak Portuguese well, I often seemed lost, and I spent the first day and a half wearing a corporate-branded bandana on my head (I was shamed into removing it during the march, and I would find out later that more than one person had thought poorly of it.) More to the point, I was a foreigner (an
estadunidense!), but unlike all the other foreigners I wasn't making a documentary or writing a news article, so why the heck would I want to be there? (Apparently the US consul had recently made an investigation into possible links between the MST and the FARC guerrillas in Colombia--a silly idea if you know thing one about the MST--and so there was a fear of "spies.") Thank goodness Diana was there to vouch for me, or else I might have been frozen out.
I met Diana in Salvador. At the time she was living in Vila Brandão, the same neighborhood as Avery. We only hung out a couple of times, but I was duly impressed by her: a Brown University student from Oklahoma making a documentary about participatory budgeting in a city in Bahia, she had come upon a nearby MST settlement and made connections there, and so was making a mini-documentary on that as well. I had e-mailed her on a whim, asking for help in making contacts at the march, only to hear that she herself had decided to go. I would end up using her cachet with everyone (and superior language skills) to make friends and get involved. (She would also be the key in my coming to visit MST encampments around Vitória da Conquista, where I currently write from.) And we would become friends, too, she glad to have another English speaker about for relfection's sake.
CultureAs the sun went down and I left the coordinator's meeting to wander aimlessly back among the camps, I heard group singing and followed the voices to have a look. Before I knew it, I had been ushered into the circle and handed a song sheet. At the head of the circle were several baskets of bread wreathed in flowering thrushes, accompanied by an open Bible and candles. Everyone was singing hymns (one went "the love of Jesus spreads over the land and inundates my being"); the ceremony was quite Christian in its appeals to Jesus, but otherwise had a sort of omnireligious sense to it. Then, a candle was passed around, each person taking a turn to ask a gift of the Lord (unity, fortitude, things like that)--scrambling for something in my vocabulary, the best I could come up with was
o dom da alegria, happiness. Then the bread was distributed, and happily munching my somewhat sacred snack, I wandered off again, knowing only that it was probably a prayer of thanks for food.

This would be the first of many encounters with
mística, a form of spirituality specific to the MST that mixes Christianity with farm-oriented symbolism and mysticism. The ceremonies and rites are created by the MST members themselves, and it demands creativity since there does not seem to be an institutional framework. Mística does not purport to replace the institutional Christianities here in Brasil, but given that churches are not usually accessible from MST settlements, my educated guess is that it was a spontaneous melding of the movement's principles and the spiritual needs of settlers.
Which reminds me to say: the MST is a culture. It is by nature community-oriented, in that the occupations are active creation of new communities, and the organizational hierarchy is based on these units. It is old enough now that there are children who have grown up in the movement, who learned to read by primers on agrarian reform. The innumerable MST-specific songs, mística, and ideologically-themed art and theatre I encountered impressed on me just how much creativity a is part of the movement. Combined with the "way of life" principles--nonviolence, temperance, consensus decision-making, gender equality, etc--you've got something that can encapsulate most parts of everyday living. (I wonder if unions in 1920s & 30s USA were not unlike this.)

A little bit of political theatre...
The summer camp feeling especially came home to me as I walked back to my tent past an outdoor screen showing a documentary on current President Lula's activist days, abounding campfires with the inevitable maté being passed, and small groups playing pagode and forró and music with a few dancers. It occurs to me that this is
the social event of the year, too.
The First Day of MarchingThat night I opted to rest up for my first day on the asphalt, laying myself down at 9pm. Unfortunately, the night got colder than expected; layered with three shirts and wrapping another around my head, I still woke up cramped into the fetal position (bastard who sold me the sleeping bag in São Paulo did not know what he was talking about). During brief moments of waking in the wee hours, I hear a constant chorus of cougs resounding across the camp, as if like crickets in a field. Everyone is sick to some extent, and I'm just finding out why.
I wake at 6am to raucous cheers responding each time to a repeatedly bullhorned, "Bom dia o pessoal do Sul!" (Good morning people of the South!). By the time I dazedly drag myself out of the tent, I notice that in the frenzy of activity around me, most people fully dressed and packed. I break my little camp double-time and head to the amassed groups readying to march, skipping breakfast...only to wait around for an hour, doing nothing. The reason? A decision made to wait until 8:30am so as not to disrupt traffic for the lower-class workers driving into the city (the reasoning being that the only people on the road after that time are upper-class, not needing to be in before 9am).

The march goes forth in three single-file lines, organized by state. I march with Bahia, which has been issued t-shirts for the occasion (yay for schwag) and goes second. Nearly everyone is wearing the signature vermilion MST baseball hat, and every third person seems to be carrying a similarly crimson flag. It's then that I notice everyone also has standard-issue backpacks. That's a manicured public image, if I may say so. I also notice some of the marchers carrying their sheathed machetes on their belts and am briefly reminded of the universal military tradition and prestige of carrying swords. Farmer pride, I suppose.

A lot of people are wearing flip-flops. I realize that they have been for 200 kilometers. Ouch.
Though the soundtrucks boom a nonstop of speeches and songs (might I add that MST protest songs are melodi and feature interesting rhythms--US activists could use some help on this front), they are far apart and not near my section of the march. The marchers themselves are largely quiet, besides the occasional cheer instigated by a "Viva XXXX!" People look tired after two weeks of this, and entering the capitol doesn't seem to be pumping them up at all. I notice some teenaged marchers flipping through a tattoo catalogue en route. The rush of traffic provides ambient noise to fill the silence.
Yet there is activity. Vendors of
picolé (fruit popsicles), scurry along the sides of the column, attempting to keep pace and make more than a few midday-sun-inspired sales. Meanwhile, documentary-makers (of which there are at least a dozen) weave in and out, foward and back, dropping to the asphalt for that tunnel-zoomed shot of everyone in file. Reporters also show up frequently, though I learn that only communication coordinators are allowed to talk to them--message discipline, no doubt an adaptation to the generally hostile press coverage that surely jumps on anything. Radios in peoples' hands transmit the soundtruck speeches, and "discipline" teams roam to make sure no one is screwing up the formation or wandering into traffic. (Did I mention the MST is
organized?)
We arrive on the grounds of the city stadium, our home for the next days. The march ends at noon--a short day, I am told (stories of a previous 9-hour day make me cringe). The procession finishes with a gathering in front of the soundtrucks, on top of which speechmakers thank the main organizers, give one last rally (we have arrived!), and even thank the assisting police officers who accompanied the march--one even gives a speech! (I'm just not used to seeing protestors and police publicly interacting in a friendly manner.)
Settling inThe giant tents are up by the time we get there, and almost everyone goes straight to their sleeping rolls. Full of energy due to my having skipped the previous two weeks of marching, I take to wandering. Vendors swarm gradually, creating a fair-like atmosphere. Casual litter appears multiplied by 12,000 appears almost immediately.
I find Diana and accompany her and another MST kid in search of public showers, which are found in the Parque Cidade nearby. Surrounded by weekenders working out and jogging in their bathing suits, I feel incredibly out of place in my dirty jeans and movement-emblazoned shirt. I quickly wash my hair under an outdoor showerhead and leave.
Trudging back to camp, my head begins to get foggy. Too much sun for me, and I end up spending the afternoong sitting in the shade and willing my headache not to become debilitating. I begin to understand the endemic tiredness, though I assume the MST members are used to the sun: the non-black members sport deep tanned skin, and everyone old and young seems to have a vague wrinkling in their faces. When I shake hands, I grip palms and fingers hardened and made jagged by calluses. And everyone seems to be pretty fit. The farming life, embodied.
It is at this point that it also finally hits me just how racially diverse the MST is. The distinct racial differences of the regions of Brasil are thrown together and come into stark contrast here like nowhere else (north and northeast darker skinned, south and west lighter skinned). To see my own resemblance in the white skin and European features of some of the membership breaks down the "otherness" for me--something that I find incredibly difficult to overcome in other countries and in pro-poor movements. Cohorting with Bahia, I am an outsider at first glance, but in the general mix of the movement, no one would have reason to suspect I'm not a member.
The afternoon is pleasant introductions and conversation. I manage to meet all the foreigners in the Bahia camp: beyond Diana, there's Célia, a Swiss-English woman working as gender issues coordinator for Bahia state, and Giorgio, an Italian who has been helping out on accampamentos in southern Bahia. The English language conversation is refreshing after a day of not being able to say much. I go and by a crate of
pinha fruits to split with the gathering many, in the process meeting several of the people Diana knows from her time in Bahia.
Summer Camp!After watching a live news broadcast from in front of the Bahia camp, I grab oily snacks with Diana and we head over to the youth rally on the other side of camp. Everyone under 25 has come out and crowded in front of a trio elétrico, and the atmosphere is that of a party about to happen. I am excited to shake it with a bunch of people my age.
The rally turns out to be speeches and songleading mixed with musical interludes; it appears that people are there mostly for dancing during the musical interludes. I get to hear a solid lineup of MST rally songs, but the one that I end up hearing endlessly (and thus learning) is the Hymn of the March:
| "Brasil em fileira" Marchar novamente é preciso Para manter a esperança Do povo sofrido e cansado Mas pra lutar não se cansa Em frente ó povo oprimido Homens mulheres crianças REFRÃO: Marcha com a gente marcha É o Brasil em fileira O sonho não é utopia No tremular das bandeiras Preste atenção meu pais Desperta pra realidade O que está acontecendo No campo e na cidade Só a força popular Mudará a sociedade REFRÃO |
"Brasil lined up" It is necessary to march again In order to maintain the hope Of a suffering and tired People But we do not tire of fighting In front of an oppressed People Are men, women, and children CHORUS: March with us*, march We are Brasil lined up The dream is not a utopia Found in the waving of flags Pay attention, my country Wake up to reality Of what is happening In the countryside and in the city Only a popular force Will change society CHORUS |
* This a very common, colloquial way of saying "we" that literally means "the people."
In the speeches and some of the songs I'm able to discern the common themes:
we (the poor) are Brasil, we are latinos, fight neoliberalism (specifically the USA and IMF), fight the bourgeoisie, Che Guevara, land and services now, yay for socialism. There's even some robotic fist-pumping to anthems that makes me twinge. I am curious about the rhetorical flourishes on socialism, since the movement itself is more or less about redistributing land within a market system. My guess is that socialism here is a convenient oppositional term to the capitalism of Brasil, which has thrived on entrenched inequality, but I do not really know. Something to ask about in the future.
I remember that, to many of the kids, this is the biggest social event of the year. It looks as though quite a few of the teenagers and young adults have saved a clean set of "hip," clubby clothes for just this night. The atmosphere is distinctly that of "last night at summer camp," with everyone getting ready to part ways and consequently expectations abounding, i.e. everyone's cruising for a hookup. With political speeches.
Too tired from sun to be socially adventurous, I head back to my tent and am able to pass out effortlessly despite the thumping bass of a trio blasting forró not 100 meters away.
Occupying the CapitolI am surprised to wake up at 8am--it's late! And it looks like quite a number of people are groggy from the previous night's celebrations (apparently the liquor vendors made a killing). An assembly for Bahia camp is called, where after songs and chants the rundown of the day's schedule is announced along with a motivational speech by an MST member-cum-
deputado (congressman). Shirts and hats are distributed for the day (more schwag!), and then waiting begins anew. I fill the time with several slightly confusing, well-meaning conversations.
After 11:30am rice and beans, the line up starts: Bahia will lead the pack (as the largest contingent attending). At noon the trios blare the hymn, a giant cheer goes up, and we begin moving forward, three lines as before.

Walking down the main highway into town, there's a surprisingly small police presence (in the US, this kind of thing would feature an officer on every corner). We finally have onlookers when we get toward the center of town, some of whom prove quite supportive, clapping and shouting support. Nearly every spectator is taking pictures: no doubt we are something of curios event to some. Unfortunately, this proves to be a short-lived phenomenon, as Brasília is a city designed to be as inhospitable to pedestrian traffic as is possible by means of modernist city-planning (though more on that in another post).
The first destination of the march is the US Embassy. After winding our way through deserted streets, we come to what appears to be a barracks. It appears so due to the stron contingent of military police and horse-mounted cops creating a wide perimeter in front of the embassy. The march just hangs a u-turn, with everyone dropping their trash as a sign of disrespect and, in the words of one marcher, "to take back the garbage they produce." A banner calling George Bush a terrorist is unfurled and put on display. (My opinion is that this gets
way off message in an otherwise rhetorically algined program, but it's not my movement.)

The march snakes back folded on itself until the lead part hooks a turn into...a parking garage? We actually end up travelling under one of the Ministries, using their highway access to avoid a roundabout route. (I only mention this because the effect of marching through a parking garage is to feel unbearably silly.) Back on the main highway, the march arrives at the congressional plaza and makes its way around the circuit of adjacent federal buildings. Because the march is 6 kilometers long, there is a stretch of time where the buildings of federal power are entirely encircled by red MST flags.


The march ends at the Ministry of Farming, affording a break to us while we wait an hour for the tail of the march to come in. A large placard is erected in front of the Ministry (considered to be conservative) displaying the American bald eagle with Brasil in its talons, as well as a sign proclaiming the Ministry as property of the IMF. Music, MST organizer speeches, non-MST business-suited important people making speeches--unfortunately, I just can't follow it, so I end up talking to a student from Santa Catarina and snacking relentlessly. Reporters swarm everywhere.

After a bit, there is a general call to head to the lawn in front of Congress, where four stages are set up to show political theatre. The crowds are intense, so I wander down to the middle of the lawn to gaze at the Congress building in the sunset. I am struck by the aesthetic of the entire scene: on one side, a monochrome imperial-looking modernist monolith of a building lined by motionless riot officers at set intervals; on the other, a tangled mas of red flags and shirts stirring vigorously. More and more people peel off from the theatres to go down to the moat in front of Congress and rally.

Why does this remind me of Star Wars (Empire vs Rebels)?

At some point, the crowd of people on the far side next to the Congress condenses and begins to move rapidly in one direction, the kind of movement that can only be associated with trouble of some sort. I learn later that marchers have surrounded a police car that tried to drive through the lines to the Congressional plaza, and as the car tries to back out that marchers continue to surround it and bang on the sides. People all around the lawn begin running toward the commotion--I have found that Brasilians often run
toward the scene of an accident or trouble--and it is not long before a detachment of horse-mounted cops charge into the crowd. I can only see objects being thrown before there is a rush of people running away, i.e. towards me. Fuck. "Calma!" I yell, hoping that my cool convinces people to stop stampeding, though it is not necessary since everyone turns right around and runs back toward the confrontation. This happens several times as a cycle: run to, confront, run from. A police helicopter buzzes the crowd to disperse it, blowing my hat off me head. That's when I decide I'm too hungry and tired to care about being there anymore, and I notice more columns of officers advancing on the far side of the field. As I walk away, the sound of speeches and festivities from the trios continues uninterrupted.
Morning AfterWaking up is a several stage process. Since some people start at 4am, it is a trick of deciphering when the noise level is sufficient to signal the actual beginning of the activites. After three or four false rises, I pop out my earplugs at 7am to hear the cheers of "o pessoal do Sul." Low-angle sunrays make the morning chill bearable. After a trip to the Parque Cidade with the foreigner crew yields a hot shower (in which I learn just ho sunburnt I am), an assembly is called in the nearby municipal arena to announce the results of negotiations between the MST and the government (which were occuring as the events of the previous day unfolded).
After state by state cheers and interminable playing of the Hymn, a mística begins on the arena floor. A brief parade of the MST banner is followed by the live construction of the stage: the stage is labelled "agrarian reform," and each support brought out to raise it up has a principle written on it (communication, resistance, spirit of sacrifice, discipline, etc). Clever symbolism. This is followed by a procession of members old and young, black and white, male and female, who ascend the stage an light a torch on top of a vaulted globe. With the lighting of the fire, banners drop from the globe with higher principles written on them (justice, liberty, equality, participation) and small placard with "socialism" on top of it all. The globe's sides fold out and all sorts of goodies (books, food, balloons, etc) are ejected from it, a symbolic cornucopia. It is not like anything I have seen before, insofar as its otherwise over-the-top symbolism is made effective by the extremely demonstrative and serious atmosphere.

Then the presentation of negotiation's results: it seems that concrete steps were lacking, and instead a continuation of promises predominated.
Here's what the original demands were (in Portguese only, I'm afraid). The results:
- continuation of promise to recognize officially (i.e. provide services to) 115,000 more settlements, bringing to 400,000 the total number of recognized settlements by 2006
- a change in the methodology for measuring land productivity in pro-poor terms
- promise to extend new lines of credit for settlement families
- a promise of favorable restructuring of the agency in charge of settlement recognition
- opening 1,300 jobs to expand said agency
Meanwhile, press coverage has predictably put almost all of its emphasis on the brief confrontation between the marchers and the police the night before, with a lede quote from the head of the police proclaiming that "an invasion of the Congress building" was prevented. But most everyone thought the march was successful in keeping the issues alive in national political debate. More than anything, I get the sense they are just happy to be going home.
UPDATE: BBC News had an article, as well as
Common Dreams, which talks about things more generally than my account.
The Most Important Part is in the PostscriptGiorgio decides to head to Salvador, leaving a vacant seat on one of the buses back to Bahia. After hearing about Diana's experiences and receiving friendly entreaties from some of the MST members, I decide, "Why not?" and hop on the bus.
21 hours in the bus from hell. I have come down with a cold, an inevitability of cold nights and hanging out with thousands of people minus reasonable sanitation. The bus itself seems to have no shocks left, which means I feel every bump doubly from my seat way in the back of the bus, next to the stinky bathroom. My seat is itself broken and listing to the right, dumping my legs into the aisle, which everyone trips over on their way to the stinky bathroom. Meanwhile, it turns out we travel down one of the most unmaintained sections of highway in Brasil, potholes the size of swimming pools I swear; I am literally tossed forward out of my seat a few times. Naturally, this horrible section of road happens only from 11pm to about 5am, meaning I get no sleep, except in 10 minute intervals intermittently. My headrest is sized for a shorter person, thereby putting a nasty crick in my neck, and the constant bouncing makes my knees sore (since my legs are extended out into the aisle to brace myself). I sit next to a guy who takes up one and a half seats and rebuffs my attempts at conversation. And on top of it all, I feel bad because the MST members have no money and so cannot eat when the bus driver makes stops for mealtimes.
But now I am in Vitória da Conquista in the southwest of Bahia state, visiting settlements and getting involved. You stick somewhere long enough, and people will recognize your place there.